Why raid by SF inside Pakistan is strategically brilliant

There are news doing rounds since yesterday that India conducted a special operation inside Pakistan to avenge the Uri terrorist attack. This was first published in an exclusive report by Quint. GoI has neither validated nor denied anything about this operation, which is again a very significant step (given how NDTV was given exclusive coverage during Kargil leading to big blunders by giving out Indian strategy) in maintaining operational secrecy. If it really happened (which seems to be the case given how things are signalled), then it is brilliant strategic move and signifies India has come out of age and is ready to sit on the world stage with big boys.

There could have been two conventional responses from Indian side:

– India could have used irregulars and hidden assets in Pak for the same operation but that would not have delivered the same signal as this raid would evoke in Pakistan Army’s mind. Using irregulars from Af-Pak border to come in and do the job would not generate awe and change in Indian’s stance of the past.

– Or India could have shelled Pakistan border like it did in 2015, but would have been called escalation and amounts to declaration of war without saying so.

But this raid shows some very important change in India’s posturing:
– If it is true, India will be doing what USA is doing for past decade

– Now the onus is on Pakistani army to respond and show it is not paper tiger. It is brilliant from strategic and diplomatic point of view.

– It shows Pak army weak and in a way calls out their nuke bluff, if Pak does not respond heavily to Indian instigation by selecting time and place to shoot down Pakistan soldiers.

This is probably the way to fight this war for India. You come and kill our army men, and we will just raid across and kill equal or more of your regular troops. While you send irregulars (for deniability), we send regulars (but don’t say anything). Could their have been a better way to show how impotent Pak Army actually is?

– It is not declaration of war but if Pakistan wishes India will give it war.

– It completely changes the defensive strategy India has used forever against state sponsored terrorism. This generates collateral damage and loss of face, the only thing which hurts Pakistan Army.

– To save its face if Pakistan owns up terrorists as its regulars (which basically destroys its Kashmir policy of past three decades), then it is overt declaration of war. On the other hand, India by sending its regulars shows that it has joined the league of big boys and does not care about world opinion when it comes to national security and delivering hard message to its enemies.

Indeed war should happen on time and place of India’s choosing.

  • Khaali Peeli

    There was no raid unfortunately & in my eyes, Quint has lost face.
    I guess, Army will take time in preparing for escalation ladder and thats what is happening.

    I feel Pakistan is also stunned by the reaction from Uri attack, as they didn’t expect that many soldiers to die.
    Now Indian retribution is certain.

  • Lalitaditya Muktapida

    This hasn’t actually happened. We have not yet come of age. And besides, this PM is not the kind to act on the spur of the moment. Even if we were do something like this, it would not be right now. He will do it when Pakistan least expects it. He has shown himself to be very machiavellian in the past. No reason for him to change his approach now.

  • Pingback: Game theory: what makes SF raid inside Pak optimal – YugaParivartan()